Page 3 of 8~112 min topic

Spot wrong answers

Fake-looking citations can sink a report

A citation that looks academic is not the same as a source that exists and says what you claim.

~14 min this pageEvidence practice

1Learn the idea

Read

Why fake citations happen

Models are good at the shape of references: authors, years, italics, page ranges. They are not a library catalog. They can:

  • invent article titles that sound plausible
  • mix real author names with wrong years
  • point to URLs that never existed
  • attribute a quote to the wrong paper

Looking formal is a pattern. Existence is a fact check.

Read

Verify before you format

For every AI-suggested source:

  1. Find it independently (school library search, Google Scholar if allowed, teacher-provided database).
  2. Open it (or a trusted abstract/record).
  3. Confirm the claim — does it actually support your sentence?
  4. Only then copy the citation details from the real record.

If you cannot find it in five to ten minutes, do not use it. Find a real source instead.

Read

Red flags in “helpful” bibliographies

  • Perfect page numbers for articles you cannot locate
  • Journals with slightly off names (“Nature Ecology Letters Weekly”)
  • Quotes with no page you can check
  • “According to experts” with a citation that doesn’t mention the topic

One fake citation can make a teacher doubt your whole report — even the parts you researched honestly.

Read

Safer ask

Suggest types of sources I should look for (museum site, encyclopedia, class text). Do not invent specific article titles or URLs. I will find real ones myself.

Or paste a real source you already have and ask for help formatting that — after you confirm it.

Read

Quotes need the same honesty

A citation can be real while the quoted sentence is not in that article. If AI gives you a quotation plus a reference, find the passage. No passage, no quote. Paraphrase only what you actually read, and still cite the real work. Teachers notice mismatched quotes quickly — and they read them as a trust break, not a formatting oops.

Go deeper

Before you start

Why this matters

Your report needs three sources. You ask AI to “add citations.” It returns impressive lines: Journal of Coastal Studies, Vol. 18 (2019), pp. 112–128 and a neat URL. You format the bibliography perfectly. Your teacher clicks the link — 404 — or opens a real journal that never published that article. The citation style was excellent. The evidence was cosplay.

In the wild

See how this idea shows up as a product and a company — then come back to the lesson. Skills transfer across vendors.

Check your understanding

Page assessment

Answer from memory. Completion is saved from this evidence, not from opening the next page.

1. Why can citations look real when they are not?
2. What four steps should you run before formatting a citation?
3. Name two red flags in AI bibliographies.
4. What should you do if you cannot find a suggested source?
5. How can you ask AI for source help without inviting fakes?

All responses are required.