Compare · Image · Research notes
Image generators — scored
Image tools fail on rights and iteration cost. Hold one brief constant and log edit loops.
Last reviewed: 2026-08-15. Re-run the protocol after major model or pricing changes.
How do you test image generators in 15 minutes?
- Write subject, style, must-avoid, and commercial need.
- Generate three variants in two tools.
- Score likeness to the brief and time-to-usable.
- Read the license before you ship a client asset.
What is the scoring rubric?
| Criterion | Weight | How to score |
|---|---|---|
| Brief match | 1–5 | Subject and constraints, not vibe. |
| Commercial rights | Gate | Fail unclear licenses for client work. |
| Edit loop | 1–5 | How fast can you correct one error? |
| Local control | Pass/Fail | Needed only if privacy or custom weights matter. |
Which image generator should I start with?
| Tool | Best fit | Best job | Watch-out | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Midjourney | Aesthetics | Concept art | Discord/plan friction | Often the look people mean by “AI art.” |
| DALL·E | Chat convenience | Inside ChatGPT | Less local control | Fast when you already live in ChatGPT. |
| Stable Diffusion | Local / open | Control and custom weights | Setup cost | Pick when privacy or fine-tunes matter. |
| Luma Dream Machine | Image-to-video adjacent | Motion experiments | Different job than stills | Compare also with video tools. |
Learn the craft, not just the tool
Practice the transferable habit in AI for design, then AI video tools scored, Midjourney for concept art.
FAQ
What is the best AI image generator?
Midjourney for look, DALL·E for convenience, Stable Diffusion for local control. Confirm commercial rights.
Can I use AI images commercially?
Only if the current license covers your use. Check the vendor terms for the plan you paid for.